Best Places to Stay In New York According To Reddit

Exploring the sprawling urban expanse of New York City is an adventure in itself. As you plan your visit to the city that never sleeps, a key consideration is finding the perfect place to stay. When it comes to uncovering hidden gems and insider tips, Reddit users have proven to be an invaluable resource. Drawing from the collective wisdom of passionate travelers and local residents, we’ve compiled a curated list of the finest accommodations across New York City. So, if you’re wondering where to stay in New York and yearn for an authentic experience, these suggestions for the best places to stay in New York City from the Reddit community are bound to make your trip unforgettable.

If it’s your first time visiting NYC, don’t forget to check out our New York City travel guide for helpful tips and recommendations.

Which area of New York is best to stay?

1. Chelsea

Searching for the ultimate New York City experience? Look no further than Chelsea, the crown jewel of urban living. Positioned as the best neighborhood to stay while visiting NYC, Chelsea offers a seamless blend of history and modernity that captures the heart of every traveler.

Why is Chelsea the go-to choice? Its thriving art scene brings culture to your doorstep, with renowned galleries and studios around every corner. The iconic High Line, an elevated park adorned with greenery and city vistas, provides a tranquil escape. Trendy boutiques, diverse dining options, and vibrant nightlife amplify the neighborhood’s allure.

Convenience takes center stage – Chelsea’s central location ensures easy access to top attractions, from Times Square to the Statue of Liberty. Immerse yourself in the energy of this captivating district, celebrated by Reddit users as the prime locale to reside while discovering the magic of the Big Apple.

2. Greenwich Village

Embarking on your first journey to New York City? Greenwich Village emerges as the answer to the perennial question: “What part of New York should I stay for the first time?” Nestled in this historic haven, you’ll find a microcosm of city life that’s both enchanting and accessible.

One of the Best Places to Visit in New York. Known for its bohemian spirit, tree-lined streets, and brownstone architecture, Greenwich Village offers a respite from the urban hustle. Its cozy cafés, unique bookshops, and tucked-away jazz clubs paint a portrait of quintessential New York charm.

Stay in Greenwich Village to be in close proximity to Washington Square Park – a vibrant hub of musicians, artists, and students. The Village’s artistic legacy shines through in its theaters and comedy clubs, promising evenings filled with entertainment.

Dive into the mosaic of dining choices, from classic pizzerias to upscale bistros. With its welcoming atmosphere and diverse character, Greenwich Village offers a warm introduction to the grandeur of the city. This, Reddit users attest, is why it’s the best place to stay for first-timers seeking an authentic taste of NYC’s rich culture and heritage.

3. Midtown

Curious about the ideal area to stay in New York? Look no further than the bustling core of Midtown Manhattan. Positioned at the crossroads of iconic landmarks and vibrant energy, Midtown emerges as the answer to the query: “Which area is best to stay in New York?”

From the luminous marquees of Broadway to the soaring spire of the Empire State Building, Midtown offers a cinematic backdrop for your NYC escapade. The neon-lit streets lead to world-class shopping along Fifth Avenue and cultural immersion at renowned museums like MoMA.

Stay in Midtown for seamless accessibility to Central Park’s green oasis and the electrifying Times Square. The neighborhood hums with life day and night, making it perfect for those who want to soak in the city’s pulse.

With an array of accommodations, from luxury hotels to charming boutiques, Midtown caters to various tastes. Reddit users celebrate it as the best place to stay for its unmatched convenience and proximity to Manhattan’s beating heart. Embrace the iconic spirit of New York City as you make Midtown your base for exploration and discovery.

4. The West Village

Yearning for the perfect haven as a first-timer in New York? Set your sights on the West Village, a charming enclave that warmly answers the question: “Best place to stay as a first timer?” Nestled along cobblestone streets, this neighborhood exudes an irresistible old-world charm.

The West Village offers an intimate introduction to NYC’s diverse culture. Its historic townhouses, hidden gardens, and cozy cafés create a soothing ambiance amidst the city’s vibrancy. Stroll along Bleecker Street’s boutiques and savor a multitude of culinary delights.

Stay in the West Village for a serene escape that’s still within arm’s reach of iconic attractions. Washington Square Park’s artistic flair and Hudson River Park’s tranquility provide a balanced experience.

Reddit users hail the West Village as the best place to stay for first-timers due to its unique blend of intimacy and accessibility. Embrace the neighborhood’s laid-back sophistication and become part of the story of this quaint, welcoming corner of New York City.

5. Upper West Side

Nestled between Central Park and the Hudson River, the Upper West Side stands out as one of the best places to stay in New York. With its charming tree-lined streets, iconic brownstones, and vibrant cultural scene, this neighborhood offers an unmatched experience for both tourists and locals.

The Upper West Side’s allure lies in its perfect blend of tranquility and urban vitality. The proximity to Central Park provides a serene escape from the city’s hustle and bustle, while world-class cultural institutions like the American Museum of Natural History and Lincoln Center cater to art enthusiasts. Locals and visitors alike praise the neighborhood’s safety and welcoming atmosphere, making it a preferred choice for families and solo travelers.

On Reddit’s “best places to stay in New York” discussions, the Upper West Side frequently garners praise for its accessibility to attractions, plethora of dining options, and a genuine neighborhood feel. Whether you’re strolling through the charming streets, enjoying a Broadway show, or exploring the local markets, the Upper West Side offers an authentic New York experience that’s hard to match.

6. Herald Square

Herald Square, a bustling commercial hub located at the intersection of Broadway, Sixth Avenue, and 34th Street, is a fantastic choice for your stay in New York. This vibrant district is famous for its iconic Macy’s flagship store, electrifying energy, and convenient access to some of the city’s top attractions.

For first-time visitors, Herald Square offers an unparalleled immersion into the city’s dynamic essence. Its central location puts you within arm’s reach of landmarks like the Empire State Building, Times Square, and the Theater District. The area’s excellent public transportation connections make navigating the city a breeze, easing any apprehensions that come with exploring New York for the first time.

In discussions about the “best area to stay in New York first time” on various travel forums, Herald Square consistently receives acclaim for its lively atmosphere and sheer convenience. With a plethora of shops, eateries, and entertainment options surrounding you, you’ll be right in the heart of the action, ensuring an unforgettable and authentic NYC experience.

7. Soho

Soho, a neighborhood renowned for its artistic flair and fashionable ambiance, is an exceptional choice for lodging in New York. The cobblestone streets, distinctive cast-iron architecture, and an array of galleries make Soho a haven for those seeking a blend of creativity and style.

Soho encapsulates the quintessential New York experience for tourists. The chic boutiques, art galleries, and diverse dining scene embody the city’s cosmopolitan charm. Its central location provides easy access to nearby attractions like the Statue of Liberty, One World Trade Center, and the 9/11 Memorial, making it an ideal hub for city exploration.

Sought after by tourists seeking the “best area to stay in New York for tourists,” Soho consistently emerges as a favorite. Its unique blend of cultural richness and upscale allure creates an environment that appeals to a wide range of travelers. With its artistic soul, designer shopping, and proximity to iconic sights, Soho promises an authentic New York adventure like no other.

8. Brownsville

Brownsville, a historic neighborhood brimming with character, offers a unique stay in New York. This vibrant district, known for its strong sense of community and rich cultural heritage, provides an alternative perspective of the city’s diversity.

For those seeking an offbeat experience in the “Best part of New York,” Brownsville offers an authentic immersion into the city’s fabric. Away from the typical tourist trails, this neighborhood showcases the genuine spirit of New York’s residents. Its local markets, family-owned eateries, and grassroots art initiatives reflect the heart and soul of the community.

Brownsville’s allure lies in its unfiltered representation of New York’s diversity and resilience. While not a conventional choice, it is a rewarding one for travelers who value cultural exploration and wish to connect with the city on a deeper level. Staying in Brownsville means being part of a neighborhood where stories intertwine and traditions are cherished, providing a truly enriching experience.

Recommended Articles

• Best Places to Visit In Upstate New York
• Best Places To Visit In Brooklyn
• Best Lakes in New York
• Best Towns to Stay in Finger Lakes

9. Lower East Side

The Lower East Side, a dynamic enclave teeming with history and contemporary allure, is a prime destination for an unforgettable stay in New York. This neighborhood’s eclectic blend of old and new, along with its vibrant nightlife and artistic scene, makes it a captivating choice.

The Lower East Side seamlessly combines urban accommodation with city retreats. Amidst the bustling streets, you’ll find cozy vacation rentals and unique lodging choices that offer a peaceful respite from the city’s hustle. The area’s accommodation options cater to various preferences, from boutique hotels to trendy apartments, ensuring a tailored experience for every traveler.

This neighborhood’s appeal extends beyond its lodgings. Renowned for its energetic nightlife, the Lower East Side offers an array of bars, music venues, and art galleries.

10. Williamsburg

Williamsburg, a trendy enclave nestled in Brooklyn, offers a captivating stay that seamlessly merges creativity with comfort. This dynamic neighborhood is celebrated for its artsy vibe, diverse culinary scene, and distinctive atmosphere.

Williamsburg stands out as one of the best places to stay, boasting a blend of creativity and quality places to reside. Its converted warehouses now house chic apartments and boutique hotels, offering travelers a range of lodging options that exude both style and comfort.

Beyond its accommodations, Williamsburg’s allure extends to its lively streets adorned with street art, its waterfront parks, and its selection of art galleries and independent boutiques. The neighborhood’s discussions about “quality places to reside” often revolve around its unique character and its ability to provide an immersive, local experience. I have also made a list of Things to do in Williamsburg Brooklyn, so do check it out if you’re planning a trip to this vibrant neighborhood

10 Best Hotels to Stay in New York City

1. Le Meridien on 57th

Le Meridien on 57th is hailed as one of the best hotels in New York for its seamless blend of luxury and convenience. With its prime location, right in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, guests are just steps away from iconic attractions like Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping. The hotel’s elegant design, top-notch amenities, and breathtaking city views create an unforgettable experience for visitors seeking sophistication and comfort.

2. Sohogrand

Sohogrand caters to the discerning traveler who appreciates boutique elegance and the artsy atmosphere of SoHo. Situated in a vibrant neighborhood known for its galleries and boutiques, the hotel provides a serene haven amidst the city’s energy. From chic rooms to personalized service, Sohogrand offers a unique blend of style and intimacy that resonates with guests seeking a distinctive New York experience.

3. The Marlton in the West Village

Nestled in the historic West Village, The Marlton captures the essence of classic New York with its vintage charm and modern comforts. This boutique gem attracts visitors who desire an authentic and cozy stay. With its cozy lobby, inviting restaurant, and proximity to charming streets, The Marlton showcases the intimate side of New York that’s often cherished by those who seek a genuine connection to the city.

4. Andaz 5th Avenue

Andaz 5th Avenue is a haven for culture enthusiasts seeking a contemporary experience infused with local art and flavor. Located near iconic landmarks like the New York Public Library and Bryant Park, the hotel offers a chic yet approachable ambiance. Its emphasis on modern design, immersive art installations, and neighborhood-inspired dining options makes Andaz 5th Avenue a standout choice for those who appreciate the creative spirit of New York.

5. Bryant Park Hotel

The Bryant Park Hotel stands as a symbol of luxury and sophistication in Midtown Manhattan. Boasting an enviable location near Times Square and the renowned Bryant Park, the hotel provides a refined oasis amid the city’s exhilarating energy. Its stylish design, panoramic views, and world-class amenities make it a favored retreat for visitors seeking a lavish escape in the heart of the action.

6. Refinery Hotel – New York

Refinery Hotel – New York appeals to travelers who crave an industrial-chic aesthetic coupled with modern comforts. Housed in a former hat factory, the hotel’s exposed brick walls and vintage furnishings create a unique ambiance. Situated near the vibrant Garment District and Times Square, guests are treated to a distinctive blend of history and contemporary design, making Refinery Hotel an alluring choice for those seeking an urban escape with character.

7. Pod Brooklyn Hotel

Pod Brooklyn Hotel redefines urban accommodation with its innovative approach to smart design and efficient use of space. Positioned in the trendy neighborhood of Williamsburg, the hotel offers a micro-hotel concept that caters to tech-savvy travelers. Its minimalist yet stylish rooms and communal spaces emphasize functionality without compromising comfort. For those who appreciate modern efficiency and the allure of Williamsburg’s creative scene, Pod Brooklyn Hotel delivers an exceptional stay.

8. Dream Hotel Midtown

Dream Hotel Midtown stands as a vibrant fusion of artistic luxury and nightlife allure. Situated in the heart of Midtown, the hotel is a stone’s throw away from Broadway theaters and Times Square. Its contemporary design, rooftop lounge with panoramic views, and artistic installations create an immersive experience for those who crave both cultural exploration and entertainment. Dream Hotel Midtown is an ideal choice for visitors seeking a dynamic stay that reflects the city’s vivacity.

9. Chelsea Pines Inn

Chelsea Pines Inn offers a unique homage to Hollywood glamour within the charming Chelsea neighborhood. Decorated with film memorabilia and nestled in a historic brownstone, the inn exudes a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Its personalized service, proximity to Chelsea’s art galleries, and connection to the neighborhood’s history make it a cherished choice for travelers seeking a more intimate and themed accommodation experience.

10. Hampton Inn Manhattan-Chelsea

Hampton Inn Manhattan-Chelsea combines modern comfort with unbeatable convenience. Situated in the lively Chelsea district, the hotel provides easy access to the High Line, Chelsea Market, and art galleries. With its contemporary rooms, complimentary breakfast, and a rooftop terrace with city views, the hotel offers a hassle-free and comfortable stay, making it an excellent option for travelers seeking practicality without sacrificing quality making it one of the best hotels to stay in NYC.

Pro Tip to Choose the Best One for Your Stay

When it comes to picking the perfect hotel, here’s a valuable insider tip: steer clear of overly bustling locations, particularly those adjacent to major roads or junctions. The incessant honking of taxis can become a constant backdrop, disrupting your peace for up to 18 hours a day. Amidst New York City’s vibrant energy, even windows marketed as “soundproof” might not shield you from the symphony of sirens and horns. Remember, the city’s vibrant ambiance can penetrate even the most resilient barriers, so a strategically quiet location becomes a precious asset for a truly restful stay.

Are there any areas of New York to avoid?

1. East Harlem Past ~110 St
2. Morningside Park
3. 125 Lexington 456 Stop
4. Brownsville
5. 8th Avenue from 34th-50th Streets

As you embark on your New York City journey, it’s essential to be informed about certain neighborhoods that might warrant extra consideration. Exploring the city’s diverse landscape involves not only finding the best spots but also being aware of areas that might be best approached with caution. Let’s delve into the insights that can help you navigate your way through the Big Apple’s vibrant tapestry.